Skip to main content

Why Questioning Our Place In “Real India” Is Not The Right Way To Address Our Ignorance Of Poverty

“Middle-class individuals live in a bubble unaware of the struggles of real India” - as much as someone belonging to this section of the population might want to disagree, I believe that this is true. And I believe this solely because the issues faced by lower-income families and people living in generational poverty are more than just the problem of finance. The issues lie in not having even minimal security, healthcare, education or opportunities. And we are in a bubble not because we aren’t aware of the issues, it’s because we aren’t aware of their extent. It is because we are largely preoccupied with our worries and struggles that we may find ourselves in this bubble of self-preservation and we may not even be aware of it. 



Debating about or questioning the term 'real India' and wondering whether we aren’t a part of it is going to get us nowhere because that is all we will remain doing: debating.


How many of us in class today would have had to constantly worry about not being able to afford one meal a day? Or not knowing if we would be able to pay the bus fare? Or not be able to pay a general medical practitioner’s nominal fee after falling sick? To many of us, these concerns may seem trivial, insignificant even. I think it is safe to assume that amongst us college students attending classes online, we might not have worried about completing our school education growing up. Most of us may have harboured dreams of going to college and securing a job, all while knowing that these hopes weren’t impossible or far-reaching. For people living in poverty, however, this is quite possibly a luxury to even think of. Not being able to afford even everyday necessities - let alone education or basic healthcare facilities - is unimaginable to most of us. And we know this, no doubt, having seen people struggle, I’m sure we are aware of these issues. But awareness does not equal experience and certainly isn’t enough for change to happen. 




Nobody is denying the existence of problems in the lives of middle-class individuals, but we need to understand that this problem in question isn’t even about us. Debating about or questioning the term “real India” and wondering whether we aren’t a part of it is going to get us nowhere because that is all we will remain doing: debating. And this to no effect because this isn’t our reality being questioned or debated about here. Like these two gentlemen Matt and Tushar who decided to live like the average Indian for a month, we can step into the shoes of people living in poverty to experience it for a while, taste guilt and remorse, like them and step out of it too, as they did. But to a significant portion of our population, this is the inescapable reality they have to deal with every day. 


The experiences of Matt and Tushar serve as a harrowing reminder of how little we know about the harsh everyday realities for a significant portion of the Indian population that lives below the poverty line. And even if we were aware of it, we realise how little we may have contributed to improving the situation for such people. Without having experienced it closely, we can only ever manage to scratch the surface of understanding such a multi-pronged issue that has its roots deep in our society. We need to understand that the reality of this problem is much darker and deeper than just numbers and percentages on a dashboard. Understanding that this is not about us and learning to exercise empathy is probably the first steps we need to take towards doing something about the metaphorical bubble we live in, and hopefully, improve the situation for the better. 


Labels:
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka, India

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding spectator violence among English football fans

Jane Austen was undoubtedly right when she wrote in one of her most-loved books Pride and Prejudice : “Angry people are not always wise.” Anger and the set of emotions and behaviours that accompany it, cause it or occur as a result of it, are not usually explainable with rationality. While they’re certainly not excusable, they do provide insight into human behaviour and help us answer the big questions of why and how we behave the way we do .  In July, English football fans made headlines in news reports worldwide for their hooliganism and other acts of violence after the English national team lost the final match against Italy in the Euro Cup 2020. Their aggression was well-documented across news channels and social media but since it is not particularly ‘news’, these behaviours have also been the subject of many social and behavioural psychologists’ curiosity and research for many years prior. All of these acts collectively have a term of their own - Soccer hooliganism.  Eng...
Post a Comment
Read more

Our existence is beyond numbers on a scale

The year is 2035. You log into your social media account. The first thing you see is someone sharing an account of their journey as a model over the years. It fills you with joy to see something so positive. But then, you see some troll-like account shaming this person for how they look below their photograph. That disgusts you. You log off of social media before you can hit ‘send’ on that scathing reply you spent 15 minutes typing. Not today, you decide.  Later that day, you are reminded of that random comment. You found the person who posted their photo beautiful and empowering. The person that commented below the same picture didn’t. They chose to sit behind the curtain of anonymity that the internet provided and called someone ‘wrinkly and ugly.’ That doesn’t sit right with you. You think - ‘that person’s concept of beauty must be something else entirely.’ Hmm, is it really that, though? ‘Oh! Or that maybe, they’re just a very rude and sad person hating others online.’ There. T...
Post a Comment
Read more

Can we afford total freedom of expression in India?

The short, simple answer is no. A longer answer is, however, complex to understand.  India is a diverse country, with hundreds of languages spoken and cultural groups all living within the same national border. We are governed by a government at the centre that makes and executes laws for a population of 1.3 billion people spread across the nation. It is, therefore, the government’s responsibility to ensure that peace is maintained among these diverse groups of people and that there is no outbreak of violence because of a comment or an act that can disrupt peace. While the Constitution of India recognises freedom of speech and expression as a Fundamental Right and guarantees to all its citizens the right to express themselves freely via written, spoken or printed material, we don’t have to go too far to realise that this right is not absolute.  A major socio-political challenge we face today is the intermingling of religion and politics.   These two have taken preced...
Post a Comment
Read more